中共勁敵—西太平洋的鐵三角

夏紫雲
2022-11-16
image
美澳日印四方會議首腦 (圖:Getty Images)

澳媒報道不斷提及,澳洲已與美國結盟,美戰機和戰艦已經入駐北領地的達爾文港,分析稱,明顯地澳洲已經為與中國戰爭做了準備。

彭博社觀點專欄作家 Hal Brands(哈爾•布蘭茲)為美中兩強國的競爭和潛在戰爭走訪了日本、印度、澳大利亞和英國,目的是想要深入了解在強國之戰中,這些美國最依賴的夥伴的真實立場。

雖然遼闊的太平洋將澳洲與亞洲分段,但堪培拉非常明白,如果中國與台灣有衝突,澳洲不可能不受影響。

 Brands在文章利表示,如果說日本是美國最重要的盟友,那麼澳大利亞從歷史上就是美國最信賴和忠誠的依靠。以往美國參與的各種重大戰爭,澳洲都不會缺席,如果美國和中國必有一戰,那麼澳大利亞就是美國最能依賴的「軍港」。

Brands走訪了悉尼和堪培拉,他認為由於台灣的危機,整體形式將澳洲、日本和美國推出一個西太平洋的「鐵三角」,他用「遏制德意志帝國的聯盟」來形容這樣的關係,並稱是「讓人放心卻又不安」的。

 前工黨陸克文政府執政時,澳洲拒絕在華盛頓和北京之間做出選擇,對與歷史盟友美國的關係也是避而不提。而後在自由黨政府執政時,來自北京的政治滲透和賄賂引發朝野震動,澳洲社會的輿論為此開始轉向。 

2020年COVID疫情之初,莫里森政府公開支持對COVID-19病毒 (時稱,武漢病毒)的起源進行獨立調查,中共因此對澳大利亞實施惡意的經濟報復。Brands表示,在堪培拉的一位國防專家稱,「澳大利亞是沒有辦法在中國人主導的地區生存」,「(北京)希望成為澳洲的「總督府」,要不聽從北京的或者選擇承擔後果。 」

 而北京在南太平洋海域的影響日漸擴大,並多次在自由海域的南海航道上對澳洲巡邏艦和巡邏機作出挑釁性的行為,引發了澳大利亞對該地區航道和海道的擔憂。

 近年來,華盛頓遏制中國電信企業-華為在美國的發展,澳洲也拒絕華為進入澳洲基建,美國、英國和澳洲創建了新的安全組織AUKUS,同時澳政府最近與日本簽署了一份聯合聲明,兩國承諾「就可能影響我們主權和地區安全利益的突發事件」進行磋商和合作。

 Brands分析道,當今的澳大利亞和日本是一個非凡的歷史轉變,1942 年時,澳大利亞北部擔心日本入侵,如今,日軍正準備與澳大利亞軍隊在那裡一起訓練。與日本一樣,澳大利亞也在努力增強其自衛能力。

 據澳媒報道稱,作為美澳軍事聯盟協議,具有核能力的美國 B-52 轟炸機將很快在澳大利亞北部運行。 AUKUS去年宣布將生產核動力攻擊潛艇和(更快)無人水下航行器和其他先進海洋防禦軍事設備。

 根據媒體的報道,澳大利亞似乎也可能租用一艘或多艘美國攻擊潛艇,直到根據 AUKUS 協議建造的潛艇準備就緒。隨著國防開支的增加,澳洲對網絡戰和情報能力的投資也在增加。Brands說:「澳大利亞軍隊規模小,距離台灣海峽遠。澳大利亞人不會有大量的火力來為台灣的戰鬥做出貢獻。」 

Brands在文章中寫道,曾有澳大利亞官員表示,在一場勝敗差距微乎其微的衝突中,澳洲的軍隊可能發揮關鍵性的作用。 「澳大利亞在大局中,希望使用一種地理分工的方式,澳洲利用空中和海上的力量來確保東南亞地區的暢通無阻,日本則希望控制東北部的亞洲,美國會直接破壞外力對台灣的入侵和封鎖,」該官員說。 

 有預測稱,在台海衝突中,美國空軍和海軍陸戰隊可能會從澳大利亞基地開展行動。澳大利亞的太空、網絡戰和情報資產將起到至關重要的作用。

Brands認為,「距離」在美中爭奪中並不是澳大利亞面臨的唯一困境,還有未來軍備上的發展,包括資金。有澳媒分析稱,無論是對中國還是美國,澳洲與盟友或軍事夥伴深化合作都會引發澳人對本國主權的擔憂。儘管如此,澳媒近期的民調顯示,超過半數澳洲民眾贊成如果美國在中國入侵台灣的時候,出手保護的話,那麼澳洲也該出兵保衛台灣。

但是,直至今日,澳洲Anthony Albanese政府仍沒有公開確定澳洲的意向,不過有國防官員向Brands私下表明,如果台灣被入侵,澳洲是不會袖手旁觀的。 

 Brands在文章中用德意志帝國時期法國、俄羅斯和英國之間三方協約國的關係來形容西太平洋「鐵三角」的關係,以鬆散的聯盟來挑戰現時代專制「德意志帝國」的力量。也就是說,中國一旦對台灣發動攻擊,面對的就不只是台灣的抗戰,而是將陷入「一加三」的反侵略局面。

Brands認為,當時的三國協約沒有辦法阻止第一次世界大戰,部分原因是其「鬆散」,缺乏約束三國的條約,他警告稱,當今民主國家也面臨著類似的挑戰。 

 Brands評論道,無論日本、美國還是澳大利亞,均表示不會讓中國占領台灣,但卻從沒有正式作出承諾。而美國與日本是單獨的聯盟,美國與澳大利亞也是單獨的聯盟,澳洲與日本的盟約也表示會對攜手合作抵抗危及安全的因素。但目前並沒有機制將三國或四國(日本、美國、澳大利亞和英國)視為一個機制,也就是說如果四個國家的其中一個受到攻擊的時候,並沒有一個確保機制的存在,當然也沒有一個指揮機制讓聯盟囯能有效的共同作戰。

  Brands認為,有著第一次世界大戰的前車之鑑,幾個聯盟國之間依然保持「模糊」狀態是需要考慮的。

有分析稱,如今的台海危機有著一觸即發的危險,而權力結構或國際形式的改變或許都會加深這個危機。「澳洲官員向我說道,五年內澳洲很難將軍事力量大幅提升,因此加強震懾或是最好的辦法。」 Brands表示,華盛頓和日本都希望北京明白,如果北京對台灣出手,面臨的將是強大的民主聯盟。

編者按: Hal Brands(哈爾•布蘭茲)是彭博社觀點專欄作家,也是約翰霍普金斯大學高級國際研究學院的特聘教授,最近與人合著了《危險地帶:與中國即將發生的衝突》一書,他也是國務院外交政策委員會的成員。

評論 (139)

avatar

Ubdzgv

2023-03-31 8:34 pm

viagra in usa cialis woman buy cialis 40mg sale

avatar

Mhuumf

2023-03-30 3:20 pm

purchase zocor online order phenergan sildenafil next day delivery

avatar

Pdwlld

2023-03-30 2:06 am

cost avlosulfon 100mg avlosulfon 100mg cheap buy atenolol 100mg

avatar

Rpclan

2023-03-28 8:09 am

omnicef online buy purchase cefdinir online cheap buy protonix 40mg generic

avatar

Xjvogs

2023-03-26 10:14 am

order azathioprine 25mg generic naprosyn for sale buy naprosyn 250mg pill

avatar

Wnythw

2023-03-26 6:03 am

doxycycline price buy acyclovir 800mg for sale order acyclovir 800mg sale

avatar

Bjmlja

2023-03-24 11:02 am

dutasteride canada cephalexin 250mg brand buy xenical 60mg generic

avatar

Zejawv

2023-03-23 7:01 pm

buy prednisolone pill brand lasix 40mg buy furosemide generic diuretic

avatar

Ckwwrr

2023-03-22 11:56 am

provigil 100mg for sale buy generic modafinil 200mg oral metoprolol 100mg

avatar

Uxjiuv

2023-03-21 8:13 am

buy accutane sale zithromax cost buy zithromax 500mg without prescription

avatar

Xahazc

2023-03-18 11:51 pm

ivermectin 4 mg purchase stromectol sale deltasone 40mg generic

avatar

Cwpmey

2023-03-18 10:40 am

zofran 8mg us amoxicillin 500mg usa bactrim 480mg pill

avatar

Iwnurf

2023-03-16 10:42 pm

purchase isotretinoin online cheap isotretinoin uk order generic ampicillin

avatar

Mlzept

2023-03-16 11:18 am

fildena 50mg cost order proscar 5mg online cheap order finasteride 5mg pill

avatar

Zbpwcf

2023-03-15 1:50 am

clomid 50mg canada order clomiphene pill generic prednisolone 40mg

avatar

Qljhsb

2023-03-14 1:54 pm

buy prednisone 40mg online cheap cost amoxil 250mg order amoxicillin online cheap

avatar

Abiexf

2023-03-13 4:46 am

buy metformin 1000mg online buy glycomet 1000mg nolvadex 10mg cheap

avatar

Xzfotw

2023-03-12 7:53 pm

provigil buy online generic stromectol 3mg promethazine pill

avatar

Funkmc

2023-03-11 5:02 am

order minocycline 50mg generic generic terazosin terazosin 5mg drug

avatar

Ailfmi

2023-03-10 11:48 pm

buy cialis 20mg generic viagra reviews cheap erectile dysfunction

avatar

Bylnsp

2023-03-09 2:08 pm

order esomeprazole online brand esomeprazole 20mg lasix order

avatar

Pfskji

2023-03-09 9:04 am

cialis oral Buy now cialis cheap viagra for sale

avatar

Qwcede

2023-03-08 2:04 am

tadacip 20mg sale plavix for sale buy trimox 250mg generic

avatar

Hmbfuz

2023-03-07 7:02 pm

tricor 200mg us buy sildenafil 100mg without prescription sildenafil 100mg pills for sale

avatar

Bskewm

2023-03-06 12:06 am

doxycycline 100mg price generic chloroquine methylprednisolone tablet

avatar

Kczwgk

2023-03-04 7:33 pm

pepcid 20mg ca pepcid 20mg us order mirtazapine generic

avatar

Fgpooy

2023-03-04 11:39 am

buy indocin 50mg sale flomax 0.2mg oral order cenforce sale

avatar

Dmessr

2023-03-03 7:23 am

brand nortriptyline purchase pamelor for sale buy generic paxil

avatar

Mwfxrt

2023-03-02 9:10 pm

dapoxetine 30mg pills avanafil generic order motilium 10mg

avatar

Vxfcjl

2023-03-01 7:33 pm

fosamax oral alendronate 35mg drug order ibuprofen 400mg pill

avatar

Htfsgk

2023-03-01 10:48 am

generic amoxil 1000mg stromectol for humans for sale stromectol tablets uk

avatar

Zjheun

2023-02-28 7:37 am

coreg 6.25mg oral buy coreg 6.25mg online order generic amitriptyline

avatar

Kubafk

2023-02-25 10:51 pm

buy generic digoxin 250mg telmisartan 80mg oral cost molnunat 200 mg

avatar

Ppklid

2023-02-24 11:48 am

acetazolamide pills buy diamox 250 mg azathioprine 50mg generic

avatar

Zbslwv

2023-02-23 1:00 pm

order asacol 400mg pill order irbesartan 150mg generic buy avapro 150mg

avatar

Anhvwi

2023-02-22 10:20 am

cost olmesartan 20mg buy olmesartan without prescription depakote 500mg cost

avatar

Mudrpi

2023-02-21 7:59 pm

buy doxycycline generic cleocin online order cleocin 300mg over the counter

avatar

Yxohdt

2023-02-20 2:07 am

cheap essay help purchase azulfidine generic buy sulfasalazine online cheap

avatar

Godnve

2023-02-19 5:43 pm

order altace 10mg online cost amaryl buy generic etoricoxib 120mg

avatar

Dbfjsy

2023-02-18 6:19 am

nifedipine 10mg cheap cost fexofenadine 120mg buy fexofenadine 120mg online cheap

avatar

Nmocvf

2023-02-18 1:14 am

live dealer blackjack writing dissertation service order an essay online

avatar

Myufrh

2023-02-16 5:35 pm

real online casino online casino real money casino online roulette real money

avatar

Okmzfs

2023-02-16 11:55 am

ivermectin 3mg dose cost symmetrel 100mg order avlosulfon 100 mg pill

avatar

Vwipix

2023-02-15 7:56 am

real casino slot machine games playing poker online for money online gambling

avatar

Fuitrd

2023-02-15 12:21 am

canadian cialis and healthcare best male ed pills tadalafil 10mg drug

avatar

Nwkmtp

2023-02-13 10:53 pm

buy cialis 10mg online cheap Cialis buy online win real money online casino for free

avatar

Debnjz

2023-02-13 1:13 pm

singulair 10mg pills singulair 10mg drug viagra overnight shipping

avatar

Haaaei

2023-02-12 9:48 am

oral actos 15mg buy viagra online cheap usa viagra sales

avatar

Lxtdyj

2023-02-11 10:07 pm

albuterol online buy order pantoprazole pills cipro 500mg usa

avatar

Zkjxis

2023-02-11 12:43 am

brand tiotropium bromide buy generic minocin brand terazosin 5mg

avatar

Zmjlhz

2023-02-10 10:13 am

order naprosyn 500mg online cheap lansoprazole price order generic lansoprazole 30mg

avatar

Ivahbl

2023-02-09 8:08 am

clarithromycin 500mg usa buy generic clarithromycin meclizine 25mg brand

avatar

Puhrad

2023-02-08 11:13 am

buy terbinafine 250mg for sale buy amoxicillin 500mg generic amoxicillin oral

avatar

Mresbz

2023-02-07 12:56 am

tadalafil 10mg price indocin 50mg generic indomethacin 75mg brand

avatar

Oamojv

2023-02-05 3:29 pm

buy retin cream online cheap order generic retin gel avanafil drug

avatar

Jtrjuy

2023-02-04 6:30 am

cheap deltasone 20mg order minipress generic mebendazole tablet

avatar

Dbambu

2023-02-04 12:41 am

buy fildena 50mg online budesonide for sale online budesonide allergy nasal spray

avatar

Ntxvyz

2023-02-02 7:41 am

casinos online free online slots provigil 200mg sale

avatar

Nsyvzb

2023-01-31 6:26 pm

order zithromax pills neurontin 800mg cost buy gabapentin 800mg generic

avatar

Uykhly

2023-01-31 4:41 pm

online slot games tadalafil generic name cialis sale

avatar

Wmpkhk

2023-01-30 9:13 am

viagra 25mg viagra sildenafil 25mg buy tadalafil 20mg online

avatar

Ntiajd

2023-01-30 5:10 am

prednisone 20mg brand prednisone pill buy amoxicillin 1000mg generic

avatar

Faqewp

2023-01-29 4:00 am

sildenafil pills 200mg lamictal 50mg without prescription order lamictal 200mg generic

avatar

Agtpvk

2023-01-28 6:20 pm

academicwriting brand stromectol 12mg ivermectin cream 1%

avatar

Zldfkz

2023-01-27 11:12 pm

desyrel canada suhagra us cost sildenafil 100mg

avatar

Bbyeld

2023-01-27 6:46 am

free spins no deposit us online casino real money no deposit cialis 5mg canada

avatar

Vkcecx

2023-01-26 1:46 pm

buy ceftin pills order robaxin pills purchase robaxin for sale

avatar

Kodyrb

2023-01-25 5:18 pm

buy sildenafil 50mg sale viagra on line buy tadalafil 20mg pill

avatar

Cnxiyi

2023-01-24 3:38 pm

buy cephalexin for sale order cleocin sale order erythromycin generic

avatar

Wdfumr

2023-01-24 6:45 am

diflucan 100mg usa buy viagra 100mg generic order viagra 50mg online

avatar

Nqwzdw

2023-01-23 10:40 am

metronidazole oral metronidazole cost buy trimethoprim online

avatar

Pokeyy

2023-01-23 2:03 am

purchase zocor online cheap order generic valacyclovir 500mg order proscar 5mg for sale

avatar

Zsyyxf

2023-01-22 6:04 am

buy tadalafil 20mg online cheap tadalafil online buy ciprofloxacin 500mg cheap

avatar

Tlwzlc

2023-01-21 5:35 am

flomax 0.4mg generic buy aldactone 100mg online buy spironolactone pills

avatar

Uqiosp

2023-01-20 4:08 pm

empire casino online gambling online online casinos for real money

avatar

Hszcdj

2023-01-20 12:44 am

purchase ranitidine generic ranitidine sale cheap celebrex

avatar

Mwvufq

2023-01-19 10:57 am

buy colchicine 0.5mg generic brand colchicine real money blackjack

avatar

Qaqjhp

2023-01-18 7:40 pm

imitrex 50mg cheap levofloxacin 500mg usa order avodart 0.5mg

avatar

Hlziku

2023-01-18 5:55 am

order ozobax generic toradol 10mg oral toradol 10mg brand

avatar

Wsniql

2023-01-17 2:58 pm

losartan 25mg tablet buy topiramate 100mg pill purchase topamax for sale

avatar

Vyimjd

2023-01-17 1:07 am

motilium sale tetracycline 500mg usa order generic flexeril 15mg

avatar

Ryikpp

2023-01-15 8:27 pm

buy allopurinol 100mg generic allopurinol drug ezetimibe sale

avatar

Olfrvk

2023-01-13 12:02 pm

tadalafil buy online viagra canada viagra for women

avatar

Dozwyy

2023-01-13 10:29 am

order priligy 60mg without prescription buy misoprostol 200mcg generic buy synthroid 100mcg for sale

avatar

Mflmgx

2023-01-12 5:35 am

triamcinolone 4mg cost aristocort canada clarinex 5mg brand

avatar

Phxilv

2023-01-12 1:30 am

tadalafil 20mg oral buy generic tadalafil sildenafil 100mg usa

avatar

Sxiupa

2023-01-10 11:40 pm

order clomid pill buy generic clomiphene 50mg online casino usa

avatar

Gwjnjj

2023-01-10 10:52 am

write essay service mba essay service sildenafil 100mg generic

avatar

Qzycbg

2023-01-09 5:48 pm

buy levitra 20mg buy levitra 10mg online buy medrol 8 mg

avatar

Nsyqrv

2023-01-09 5:37 am

essay writing sites play casino online free slot machine games

avatar

Muyshn

2023-01-08 4:11 am

metoprolol 50mg cheap purchase metoprolol online brand vardenafil 20mg

avatar

Azpskt

2023-01-07 12:13 am

buy prilosec 20mg essays help casino free spins no deposit

avatar

Jhrkik

2023-01-06 11:44 am

purchase linezolid pill real money slots free spins no deposit slot machines

avatar

Dkbttg

2023-01-05 8:02 pm

viagra 100mg drug lisinopril 5mg generic lisinopril 5mg us

avatar

Drnsgn

2023-01-05 7:45 am

clozaril for sale combivent 100mcg usa dexamethasone 0,0,5 mg ca

avatar

Gyrxup

2023-01-04 3:57 pm

amlodipine 10mg pills us viagra buy tadalafil 40mg online cheap

avatar

Uxpzuk

2023-01-04 3:34 am

purchase olanzapine without prescription olanzapine canada buy diovan pills

avatar

Ywnpyi

2023-01-03 11:53 am

oral glucophage cialis savings card how to get cialis

avatar

Wamdpq

2023-01-02 11:21 pm

itraconazole 100mg ca buy itraconazole 100mg without prescription order tinidazole 300mg online cheap

avatar

Hymfft

2023-01-02 7:43 am

order chloroquine 250mg generic baricitinib 4mg tablet olumiant ca

avatar

Ulrsfl

2023-01-01 6:32 pm

brand cialis 10mg clomipramine 50mg pill anafranil without prescription

avatar

Mbifjm

2023-01-01 4:25 am

buy lasix 100mg order doxycycline 100mg generic hydroxychloroquine drug

avatar

Ajmqvp

2022-12-31 3:25 pm

cheapest cialis online buy generic cialis 40mg buy sildenafil tablets

avatar

Tswhyz

2022-12-31 12:34 am

zithromax brand buy neurontin 600mg sale gabapentin 100mg cost

avatar

Bqqpts

2022-12-30 11:33 am

nootropil ca buy viagra online cheap sildenafil dosage

avatar

Xngfvq

2022-12-29 8:38 pm

purchase accutane online cheap order accutane 10mg sale cheap prednisone 20mg

avatar

Xadqdg

2022-12-28 11:05 pm

luvox 50mg uk duloxetine 40mg canada glucotrol 5mg ca

avatar

Yhrupo

2022-12-28 4:05 pm

provigil 100mg tablet cheap provigil stromectol for sale

avatar

Ffqlnh

2022-12-27 6:51 pm

order provera 10mg generic order medroxyprogesterone 10mg online order periactin 4mg without prescription

avatar

Unlfxi

2022-12-27 2:50 am

avlosulfon over the counter perindopril sale generic perindopril 4mg

avatar

Vhjpba

2022-12-26 2:42 pm

order revia generic revia pill buy aripiprazole 20mg sale

avatar

Qjomwo

2022-12-25 10:35 am

cialis Buy online cialis buy sildenafil pills

avatar

Knrjhx

2022-12-24 6:12 am

zoloft order online buy generic sildenafil 200mg sildenafil overnight delivery

avatar

Bpxhuw

2022-12-23 4:39 pm

buy generic molnunat 200 mg purchase molnunat prevacid canada

avatar

Dtadye

2022-12-22 8:51 pm

bupropion online buy buy quetiapine for sale seroquel cheap

avatar

Qeomwi

2022-12-22 8:14 am

imdur 40mg for sale imuran pills micardis 20mg generic

avatar

Enpuoc

2022-12-21 3:18 pm

tacrolimus 1mg sale purchase prograf generic cheap ursodiol

avatar

Gyaguv

2022-12-21 4:19 am

olmesartan 10mg pills buy olmesartan 10mg online cheap acetazolamide over the counter

avatar

Ltcomk

2022-12-20 10:30 am

alendronate 70mg price purchase alendronate pills famotidine 40mg usa

avatar

Pymicw

2022-12-19 5:59 am

buspirone 5mg brand cordarone 200mg us brand oxybutynin 2.5mg

avatar

Cbhorx

2022-12-18 8:01 pm

clonidine 0.1mg without prescription order antivert 25 mg pill brand spiriva

avatar

Pnnwju

2022-12-18 1:40 am

purchase altace online cheap purchase temovate for sale buy azelastine 10ml online cheap

avatar

Ccragy

2022-12-17 4:47 pm

buy doxycycline 200mg online doxycycline 200mg us buy furosemide 40mg online cheap

avatar

Gvsapn

2022-12-17 4:43 am

provigil 100mg ca order generic diamox 250mg acetazolamide 250mg oral

avatar

Ftqdkv

2022-12-16 1:51 pm

buy isotretinoin 20mg pills buy stromectol for humans ivermectin generic name

avatar

Bmoktv

2022-12-16 1:00 am

cialis kaufen ohne rezept cialis 20mg ohne rezept viagra generika

avatar

Bhtmkq

2022-12-14 9:34 pm

cost prednisone 10mg cheap viagra 50mg order sildenafil for sale

avatar

Ohyhxw

2022-12-14 12:21 pm

tadalafil generique pas cher tadalafil comprimГ© sildenafil 25mg generique

avatar

Aeujst

2022-12-13 9:54 am

buy arimidex for sale how much is viagra in the philippines sildenafil professional

avatar

Uhtllj

2022-12-13 5:58 am

cialis price costco Buy viagra in us order sildenafil 100mg pill

avatar

Zvanax

2022-12-11 4:58 pm

accutane online order cheap amoxil azithromycin without prescription

avatar

Zghejp

2022-12-10 5:35 pm

order tadalafil 10mg tadalis over the counter diclofenac order online

avatar

Wnahxv

2022-12-09 12:42 pm

purchase lamictal pills buy lamictal 50mg generic retin online order

avatar

Ejzvyc

2022-12-08 6:58 am

buy suhagra sildenafil usa estrace 1mg generic

avatar

Vcrqdw

2022-12-06 11:27 pm

oral fildena buy nolvadex 20mg pills robaxin cheap

avatar

Fowhmh

2022-12-05 4:09 pm

ampicillin brand acillin cheap oral erythromycin 250mg

avatar

Lvxkun

2022-12-04 8:56 am

aldactone 25mg cheap valacyclovir 500mg sale diflucan 100mg sale

avatar

Erxayf

2022-12-03 1:10 am

order dutasteride generic buy tamsulosin 0.4mg pills order zofran 8mg

avatar

Axyylc

2022-12-01 6:43 am

buy generic levaquin 250mg purchase levofloxacin pills

發表評論

您的郵件地址未經允許不會泄露給第三方。

猜你喜歡

【人在澳洲】黑社會政黨

扶搖  2023-03-22

編輯推薦

瀏覽最多

彭帥被刪微博全文

米蘭  2021-11-04

image